Etsy was built on one promise: handmade. AI is breaking it.

Visuals by:
Simona Gjorgiev

Etsy was built on one promise: handmade, by a real person.

It started in 2005, in a Brooklyn apartment, as a small place where people who made things by hand could sell them to people who wanted something handmade. A very nice idea. You could buy a knitted scarf, a hand-thrown mug, a painting, or a ring someone bent and soldered at their own kitchen table. It was a chance for creators to make money from a hobby, creativity, talent, and skills. You weren't buying from a factory, but a person, and often you could message that person and feel them on the other side. For twenty years, that promise is what made Etsy special. 

Well… that promise is now expensive, and hard to keep. This morning, over coffee, a colleague asked me if I’d seen what’s happening to Etsy. I hadn’t, so I went looking. Reddit first, because people are most honest there, then some articles, a few YouTube videos… and I couldn’t stop reading. Because two things are happening to Etsy at once, and both of them are about AI.

I love arts and crafts, so I didn’t like this news. It's fine that AI is everywhere now. We use it, we build with it, we go with the flow. But can we leave art out of it? Please? 

Why art is the one place AI shouldn't go

We wrote a while ago that AI has no emotional intelligence. It can copy the look of a feeling, never the feeling itself. Art is made of feeling. It's the one kind of work where the emotion isn't a nice extra, it's the whole point.

What makes something art and not just a nice object? It's a person putting something of themselves into the world, a fear, a joy, a loss, a question they couldn't say out loud any other way. A machine can arrange colors that look pleasing. It cannot have the sleepless night that made someone paint the way they did. The object might look the same. The soul behind it isn't there, and over time, people feel the difference even when they can't name it.

What happened with Etsy

Two fights are going on, and it helps to see them apart.

The first is that Etsy got flooded with AI. Real makers started noticing their work was drowning under machine-made products pretending to be handmade. A pet-portrait artist said AI versions were outranking her real paintings and selling for a fraction of the price. People bought crochet patterns with AI-generated photos, then got home and made something that looked nothing like the picture. One person paid for woodworking plans that turned out to be a free design from somewhere else, with a photo stolen from another company. The handmade marketplace was filling up with things no hands ever touched.

Etsy tried to answer that in October 2026 with new rules. Sellers now have to show at least one real, unedited photo of the actual item. Listings made entirely by bots are banned. AI-generated patterns and recipes are banned unless you show a real finished result. It sounds good on paper. But makers are skeptical, and with reason. One crochet artist found an AI copy of her pattern posted six days after the new rules, with all eight images AI-generated. Her words stayed with me: "They're addressing the problem, but they're not really doing anything about it. The problem is people aren't being honest."

Then came the second fight, the one that broke people's hearts. Etsy updated its terms, effective December 16, to add the right for Etsy "and our third party partners and vendors" to use sellers' content to train AI. So the same platform fighting AI fakes with one hand reached out with the other and said it could feed the real artists' work into the machine. And it landed right in the busiest selling season of the year.

Etsy says it isn't training AI to copy anyone or replace anyone's creativity, that it uses this for things like search and fraud detection. Maybe so. But it never clearly said whether those "third party partners" can train their own models on your art, and there's no simple way for a seller to say no. For a lot of artists, that uncertainty was enough.

Etsy artists are leaving the platform

Yes! They're leaving and post on socials about it! Some are closing shops they spent years building and posting goodbye letters drawn in their own styles, which might be the saddest and most beautiful protest I've seen. Some are moving to small anti-AI marketplaces like Marmalade Handmade, still tiny next to Etsy. Others are done with platforms altogether and are asking their customers to buy from them directly, person to person, the way it used to be before any marketplace stood in the middle.

Nobody really knows where this lands yet. The small human-only places might grow into something real, or they might stay small. What's clear is that many makers decided their work was worth more than a line in someone's terms of service, and they walked.

What era do we live in, anyway? 

Here's where I want to zoom out, because this is bigger than one website.

Art and the artist have been with us since the very beginning. People started to know themselves through art. The first proof we have of human beings is their mark, the drawings on cave walls. And every age since, every era, we recognize it and give it a name through its art. Classicism, the Renaissance, Baroque, Romanticism, Realism, Impressionism, Modernism. Not only in painting, but in literature, in architecture, in music too. We date ourselves by what we made and how we made it. Art is how each era left its fingerprint.

So what is this time? What do we call now? It's the age of AI, and that's fine. But I don't want it to also become the age of low quality, of rushing, of everything fast and flat, of people drifting away from one another. I don't want the fingerprint of our era to be a thing no hand ever touched.

And it seems I'm not alone in feeling this. Even Cambridge Dictionary named “human” as its 2026 Word of the Year. They chose it for a renewed appreciation of human creativity, connection, and authenticity in a world run by AI. Think about what that says. Of all the words, the one that defined this year is the one we're suddenly afraid of losing. There's clearly a deep need, under all of this, not to forget that, at the end of the day, we are people.

Conclusion

My honest view hasn't changed across any of these blogs. AI has huge benefits. I use it every day, our whole team does, and I'd never tell anyone to put it down. For the slow parts, the heavy lifting, the work that stands between us and what matters, bring it in.

But art? No.

That's the one place I'd hold the line, and I think I always will. Not because AI can't make something that looks like art. It can. But... art was never about the look. It was about a person being in it. The moment we let the machine make that too, we've handed over the one thing that was only ever ours.

Use AI for almost everything. Leave art to the humans. 

If you enjoyed this one, there’s plenty more where it came from, over on our blog.

‍

Irina Tumbovska-Taleska
Head of Growth

A Head of Growth at Solveo. She writes copy, runs the outbound and paid campaigns that carry it, and analyses the KPIs that say whether it worked — a rare full loop from first draft to performance report. She believes brands connect through authentic narrative, not repetition. Her writing explores a philosophical view of AI, Ai agents, automation, and adoption, and she hosts Solveo's Growth Talks series.

Latest Insights
Etsy was built on one promise: handmade. AI is breaking it.
Read more  →
AI research, explained.
Read more  →
Market Gap Watchlist 2027 (Part 3): Four Gaps in Trust and Demography
Read more  →
View More

Implement change.
Automate smarter with AI.

Be on top of global trends.

Get in touch